Frequently asked questions
Answers for HR and benefits leaders on setup, contributions, eligibility, participation, and taxes.
Learn more about Peanut Butter
A one-minute introduction.
About Us
For a lot of people, peanut butter is the only thing they can afford to eat in college. It’s our honor to pay homage to the hard work and sacrifice that many endured to earn their degree and qualify for great jobs with our clients.
What did you eat in college?
General
Student Loan Assistance is an employee benefit that helps employers meet their hiring and retention goals by:
- providing employees with online resources to manage their student debt (Student Loan Resources), and
- giving employers a convenient way to make monthly contributions to employees’ student loans (Student Loan Repayment).
To attract, retain, and engage the most ambitious and well-trained workers. See the business case.
Access has doubled since 2020, to 8% of U.S. civilian workers in March 20261. Among organizations, 9% offered student loan repayment in 2024, up from 7% in 20222, and another 18% were considering it3.
Peanut Butter partners with employers across the United States, including many in these industries.
Process
Peanut Butter provides the software and support that make it easy for employers to offer Student Loan Assistance. Pick the plan that’s right for your company.
Our standard price list and a budget calculator are on the pricing page. Most of an employer’s budget is its own contributions to employees’ loans.
By ACH debit. Each month, your company’s contributions and Peanut Butter fees are debited from the bank account you designate. Once the debit clears, your contributions are sent to each enrolled employee’s student loan servicer as an additional payment.
Peanut Butter does not fund contributions or lend money. Invoice funding is available on request.
Employers typically spend about an hour setting up their program, and one person spends about 20 minutes a month on administration. That person is responsible for maintaining eligible employee information in Peanut Butter.
- Start low and grow. Begin with a modest monthly contribution and consider increasing it in the second plan year.
- Keep it simple. Make the program available to all full-time employees, just as most companies offer health insurance.
- Share accountability. Employees remain responsible for their minimum payments; your contributions help them get out of debt faster.
Contribution
The most common contribution, across industries and geographies, is $50 a month. At $50 a month, the average participating borrower gets out of debt in about 8 years instead of 10 and saves nearly $7,000 in principal and interest4.
Employers in high cost-of-living areas, or with many employees holding advanced degrees, often choose $100 a month. Some employers offer the benefit effectively at $30 a month.
No. Most companies contribute until the employee’s loans are paid off. A $50 contribution several years in is a modest investment in keeping a long-tenured employee, and many employers like being part of the employee’s moment of becoming debt-free.
Peanut Butter supports tiered plans based on tenure or time in the program, but most successful plans keep it simple with one flat dollar amount. A modest contribution makes a noticeable difference.
Contributions are tax-deductible as a business expense, like other compensation and benefit costs. Outside a Section 127 plan, contributions are taxable compensation to the employee. Through a Section 127 plan, you can contribute up to $5,250 per employee per year tax-free, permanently. Learn how tax-free contributions work.
No. Making a 401(k) contribution contingent on an employee’s choice of another benefit violates the contingent benefit rule. SECURE 2.0 created a narrow exception that lets employers treat student loan payments as elective deferrals for a retirement match, but that match does not reduce the loan and adds plan amendments and nondiscrimination testing. See why direct repayment works better.
Eligibility
Most employers offer Student Loan Assistance to all full-time, benefit-eligible employees. You may also offer it to a subset of employees, or extend it to part-time employees.
Any criteria permitted by law. For tax-free plans, eligibility must not favor highly compensated employees.
We recommend against salary thresholds and degree requirements (for example, requiring a bachelor’s degree). They cause unnecessary frustration and confusion among employees.
No. The employee must be the primary borrower on the loan to qualify for Student Loan Repayment. Many employees still use the My Loans page and the Action List to manage loans for family members.
Participation
Employees with student loans are likely to participate; employees without them are likely to decline, as with other benefits.
Participation generally runs between 20% and 35% of eligible employees and rises with the contribution amount. Peanut Butter’s budget calculator estimates 20% at $30 a month, 25% at $50, and 30% at $100, a few points higher or lower in industries where more or fewer employees carry student debt.
No. Claw-backs make sense when a large benefit is paid up front. With Student Loan Repayment, contributions are small and monthly, and an employee receives one only for each month they stay.
- Meet the eligibility criteria defined by their employer;
- Submit a qualified student loan in good standing, with a balance, in their name as the borrower and, for a Section 127 plan, taken out for their own education;
- Continue making at least their minimum monthly payment;
- Abide by Peanut Butter’s Terms of Use and acknowledge its Privacy Policy; and
- Comply with company employment and benefit policies, including the company’s Section 127 plan if applicable.
Loan Qualification
Federal and private student loans qualify for tax-free contributions under a Section 127 plan when the loan was taken out for the employee’s own tuition and related expenses:
- Direct Subsidized, Unsubsidized, Consolidation, and Grad PLUS loans
- Stafford Subsidized, Unsubsidized, Consolidation, and PLUS loans
- Perkins loans
- Private student loans
These do not qualify: Parent PLUS and private parent loans taken out for a dependent; loans guaranteed or serviced by non-U.S. entities; co-signed loans where the employee is not the primary borrower; non-student debt such as personal loans, home equity loans, and credit cards; and defaulted loans turned over to collections.
A broader range, unless the employer’s policy excludes them: all the loans above, plus Parent PLUS loans, private parent loans, and student loans guaranteed or serviced by non-U.S. entities. Co-signed loans where the employee is not the primary borrower, non-student debt, and defaulted loans in collections do not qualify.
- American Education Services (AES)
- Aidvantage
- Aspire Resources
- Bank of North Dakota
- CEFCU
- Citizens
- CRI
- Earnest
- ECSI
- EdFinancial
- Firstmark
- First Tech Federal Credit Union
- HESC
- HESAA
- Kentucky Higher Ed
- Launch Servicing
- Lendkey
- MOHELA
- Navient
- NaviRefi
- Nelnet
- PenFed
- Sallie Mae
- Sloan Servicing
- THECB
- UAS
- And more
When an employee enrolls, they agree to Peanut Butter’s Terms of Use, acknowledge the Privacy Policy, agree to the company’s benefit policies (including its Section 127 plan, if applicable), and provide information about their loan. Peanut Butter confirms that:
- the loan is a student loan;
- the borrower’s first name matches the employee’s;
- the loan is in good standing and able to receive payment;
- the payment details are complete; and
- the balance is greater than $0.
A loan in forbearance can qualify; Peanut Butter reviews each loan during verification.
Implementation
Yes. Your plan can be set up and communicated to employees in about an hour: 15 minutes online and a 45-minute Program Initiation call. See the timeline.
Either works. Many employers kick off Student Loan Repayment during open or annual enrollment, and others launch it on its own. You set the plan’s effective month at setup, so employees can enroll now even if contributions begin with your next plan year.
Employees agree in the Terms of Use to continue making their minimum monthly payments under their agreement with their lender and servicer.
Contributions are applied according to the terms of the employee’s loan agreement with their lender or servicer. Peanut Butter also guides employees on asking their servicer to apply extra payments to principal where possible.
No integration is needed. Peanut Butter works alongside any payroll provider or PEO, and monthly administration takes most employers half an hour or less. For ADP clients, an integration with RUN Powered by ADP®, ADP Workforce Now®, and ADP Vantage HCM® is available through the ADP Marketplace.
No. Deducting employees’ minimum loan payments from paychecks gives them nothing they don’t already have through online bill pay, and it exposes your company to liability for payment timing, penalties, and interest.
Tax-Free
Yes. Taxable contributions are useful when an employer wants to limit eligibility to a group that includes many highly compensated employees, or to contribute to loans that don’t qualify under Section 127, such as parent loans.
Yes. Contributions are deductible as a business expense under both tax-free (Section 127) and taxable plans.
Up to $5,250 per employee per year under Section 127. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 made the student loan provision permanent and indexes the limit for inflation beginning in 2027. The limit is an aggregate cap that includes any tuition reimbursement paid under the same plan.
If your company offers tuition reimbursement, it likely does. Check with your legal department. Peanut Butter provides sample plan documents and amendments that add Student Loan Repayment to a new or existing plan; your counsel reviews and adopts them.
Federal and private student loans taken out for the employee’s own education qualify. Parent PLUS loans, private parent loans, co-signed loans where the employee is not the primary borrower, and non-student debt do not.
No. Section 127 covers employer contributions only. Employers should not process employees’ own loan payments through payroll: it can cost employees their servicer’s auto-debit discount and expose the employer to late-payment liability.
No. A Section 127 plan may not offer eligible employees a choice between educational assistance and other taxable compensation.
Not as a tax-free Section 127 benefit. It can be offered as a taxable benefit.
Yes. To qualify under Section 127, an employer must have a written plan document and give eligible employees reasonable notice of the program’s availability and terms. Peanut Butter provides a sample plan document for your counsel to review and adopt.
Yes, as long as eligibility does not favor highly compensated employees. Employers may define eligibility by job level, job type, division, location, salary, or tenure. Making every full-time employee eligible is the most common approach and the simplest way to stay within Section 127’s nondiscrimination rules.
Yes, within a limit. A Section 127 plan may not provide more than five percent of its total annual benefits to individuals who own more than five percent of the company.
Still need help? Get in touch or call 1-800-913-6651.
Notes
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, National Compensation Survey, March 2026
- SHRM Employee Benefits Survey, as reported in SHRM, “Student Loan Benefits on the Rise,” 2025: share of organizations offering student loan repayment
- International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans, Education Benefits: 2024 Survey Report: organizations offering or considering student loan repayment, and their reasons
- Peanut Butter analysis of the average participating borrower
Reviewed November 2026. Tax-free treatment of employer student loan contributions under Section 127 is permanent (One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025).