Tax-free Student Loan Repayment is now permanent under Section 127. See what it means for your company

What 400 college-educated workers told us about student loan repayment

In 2015, almost no employer offered help with student loans. Before we asked companies to try it, we wanted to know whether the people they were trying to hire would care. So we sponsored a survey of college-educated workers early in their careers and asked them, plainly, how they valued it against the benefits employers already paid for.

We published the results that December as the Millennial Benefit Preferences study. This post restates what it found, how it was run, and where its limits are, so that anyone who sees it cited can judge it for themselves.

What we found

Offers. We asked respondents to imagine job offers from two employers with identical salary, benefits, and perks, except that one also offered to contribute to their student loans. 85% said they would accept that offer; 13% said it depends, and 3% said no.

Tenure. We asked how long respondents expected to stay with an employer offering competitive salary, benefits, and perks, with and without student loan repayment. Without it, the average expected stay was 3.7 years; with it, 5.0 years, at least 36% longer (1.3 additional years). 44% said they would stay six years or more, against 19% without the benefit.

Value against other benefits. We asked respondents how they would want an employer to divide $1,000 across six benefits. On average they put $418 toward student loan repayment, $239 toward 401(k) contributions, $181 toward health insurance, $63 toward food, $38 toward gym memberships, and $35 toward the workplace environment: nearly twice as much as a 401(k) contribution and 12 times as much as a better office.

Who valued it most. A cluster analysis found that 27% of respondents valued student loan repayment 18 times as much as a 401(k) contribution and 23 times as much as health insurance contributions. That group included significantly more women and respondents of color than the sample as a whole. Separately, 73% said their employer offered at least one benefit or perk they did not value.

How it was run

FC Consulting, a group of master's degree candidates in marketing analysis at DePaul University, designed the study, fielded it, and analyzed the results. Peanut Butter sponsored it. The work ran in three phases: one-on-one interviews about benefits and perks; a test survey of 62 people in early July 2015; and a self-administered online survey open from July 26 to August 9, 2015, distributed by email, handouts, Craigslist, Amazon Mechanical Turk, Facebook, Reddit, Twitter, and LinkedIn. Of 717 respondents, 400 were ages 21 to 34, had at least some college education, and completed the survey; every result above is based on those 400. Half were women; 90% were employed; 52% were white, 17% Black, 15% Hispanic, and 11% Asian; and 16% had no student loans.

Its limits

It was a modest online sample, not a probability panel, and it measured what people said they would do, not what they did. It is also more than ten years old. We cite it alongside newer data, not in place of it.

What has changed since

The direction has held, and the evidence has grown:

  • Access to student loan repayment has doubled since 2020, to 8% of U.S. civilian workers, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (National Compensation Survey, March 2026).
  • 9% of organizations offered it in 2024, up from 7% in 2022 (SHRM Employee Benefits Survey), and employers that add it cite attracting talent (92%) and retaining employees (80%) as their top reasons (International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans, 2024).
  • More than half of working Americans told SHRM in 2019 that student loan repayment would play a role in how they evaluate job offers (SHRM and NORC at the University of Chicago, 1,084 adults).
  • 61% of 2019–20 bachelor's degree completers borrowed, averaging $30,500 per borrower (National Center for Education Statistics).
  • Among workers with a bachelor's degree or more, 36% of Black and 27% of Hispanic workers hold student debt, against 20% of white workers (Peanut Butter analysis of the Census Bureau's Survey of Income and Program Participation, 2022–2024).

The full business case, with every source, is on our business case page. The figures for recruiting on campus are on New Graduates, and the figures by race, ethnicity, and sex are on Who Holds Student Debt.


More from the blog

Become an employer of choice today