The finance view of Student Loan Repayment
For finance leaders: what it costs, what it returns, and what you control.
You control the budget
You set the amount and who is eligible
Most employers contribute $50 a month and make every full-time employee eligible.
You pay only for employees who enroll
Participation generally runs between 20% and 35% of eligible employees.
Contributions stop when employment does
Each contribution is paid monthly, only while the employee stays. No claw-back is needed.
Contributions end when loans are paid off
If a final payment overpays a loan and the servicer refunds it to Peanut Butter, it comes back to you.
You fund it monthly, by ACH
Contributions and fees are debited from the account you designate; your contributions then go to employees’ loan servicers. Peanut Butter does not fund contributions or lend money.
Standard prices are published
No implementation fee and no minimum participation charge. Pricing is based on a two-year agreement.
Most of the budget goes to your employees
Your annual budget is your contributions to employees’ loans plus Peanut Butter fees. The calculator shows both, line by line.
Tax treatment
- Contributions are deductible as a business expense
- Under a Section 127 plan, they are tax-free to the employee, up to the annual limit
- No employer payroll taxes on tax-free contributions: about $10.25 saved per $1001
Low effort, low exposure
- About an hour to set up and about 20 minutes a month to run, by one administrator
- Sample Section 127 plan document for your counsel to review and adopt
- No retirement plan amendment and no ACP testing of a match
- Employees’ own loan payments never run through your payroll
How we protect your data Direct repayment vs. a 401(k) match
Peanut Butter is a software company, not a law firm or accounting firm. This is not legal or tax advice.
Finance leaders are seeing results
“Our current Student Loan Program with Peanut Butter allows us to have a competitive advantage when engaging with potential talent.”
Notes
- Employer payroll taxes on a $100 taxable contribution: Social Security and Medicare (7.65%), federal and state unemployment taxes (about 1.6%), and workers’ compensation (about 1%); rates vary by state. Peanut Butter, Briefing on Tax-Free Student Loan Repayment, 2026 tax tables
- Peanut Butter client and client-employee data, where aggregated data analysis has been authorized: annual rate at which Student Loan Repayment participants left their employers after their first contribution, 2016–2026, compared with the average total separation rate for each participant’s industry in the same years (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey). Payoffs and employer-ended programs are not counted as departures. This compares participants with their industries, not with coworkers who did not enroll.
- Gallup, “This Fixable Problem Costs U.S. Businesses $1 Trillion,” 2019: one-half to two times the employee’s annual salary
- SHRM, 2026 Recruiting Executives Benchmarking: median time to fill, nonexecutive positions
Reviewed November 2026. Tax-free treatment of employer student loan contributions under Section 127 is permanent (One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025).