Plan Design Benchmarks and Best Practices
For HR leaders: the plan design most employers choose to attract and retain college-educated talent, and why it’s easy.
The most common plan
- $50 a month toward each participant’s loans
- Every full-time employee eligible
- No waiting period
- No contribution tiers
- No lifetime maximum
$50 a month is the most common contribution, and nearly 9 in 10 covered employees receive $100 or less. 85% of employers offer a single plan, 92% use no tiers, and 94% set no lifetime maximum.1
Best practices for each plan design choice
What we recommend, and what Peanut Butter clients do.1
Contribution amount
Start at $50 a month.
$50 is most common; nearly 9 in 10 covered employees receive $100 or less.
Eligibility
Every full-time employee.
Waiting period
None.
About half of employers have none; three months is most common otherwise.
Contribution tiers
None; one flat amount for everyone.
8% of employers use tiers; 92% offer one flat amount.
Lifetime maximum
None; contribute until loans are paid off.
6% of employers set one; 94% set none.
Graduations
Celebrate it together; overages come back to you.
About 1 in 30 participants pay off their loans each year.
When to launch
Any month, including open enrollment.
Participation
Plan on 20% to 35% of eligible employees.
Administration
One person, about 20 minutes a month.
What it achieves
- Attract: a benefit candidates notice in your offer
- Retain: contributions arrive only while employees stay
- Ease: one simple plan for HR to explain and run
By industry
Where student debt runs higher, such as dental and veterinary practices or high-cost-of-living cities, $100 a month is the next most common choice.
Industries ServedWhat administrators say
“The implementation process was simple. Ongoing administration takes minutes each month. Peanut Butter handled all of the employee-communications and enrollments.”
Notes
- Peanut Butter client data, where aggregated data analysis has been authorized: Student Loan Repayment plans, 2016–2026, as of November 2026. Each employer is counted once, by its primary plan (the plan covering the most eligible employees); figures for employees count each eligible employee under their plan; tiered plans are excluded from contribution figures.
Reviewed November 2026. Benchmarks are from Peanut Butter client programs as of November 2026.