Six questions to ask any vendor
Six questions HR leaders should ask any Student Loan Assistance vendor, including Peanut Butter.
1. Do you require a minimum headcount, such as 100 or 500 employees, to launch a program?
Minimums decide whether you can offer the benefit at all, and whether you can keep it if your headcount dips. Ask whether there is a minimum, whether it applies at renewal, and whether eligibility is limited to clients of a parent company.
Peanut Butter’s answer: No minimum. Employers of any size can launch.
2. Do you publish your full price list, or are there hidden minimums?
A published price list lets you budget before the first sales call and compare vendors on the same terms. Ask for every recurring charge, any setup or minimum charge, and what happens at renewal.
Peanut Butter’s answer: Our standard price list and a budget calculator are on our pricing page.
3. Must we use your parent company’s retirement, wealth, or other services to access your student loan benefit?
Bundling can lock your student loan benefit to an unrelated purchasing decision and make it harder to switch either product later. Ask whether the benefit is available on its own, at the same price.
Peanut Butter’s answer: Peanut Butter is independent and offers only Student Loan Assistance. Nothing else is required.
4. Do you require employees to provide Social Security numbers, dates of birth, or home addresses?
Every sensitive data element a vendor collects is one more thing that can be exposed. Ask exactly which personal identifiers participants must provide, where the data is hosted, and how often the platform is independently tested.
Peanut Butter’s answer: We do not collect participants’ Social Security numbers, dates of birth, or home addresses. We host on Google Cloud Platform (SOC 1, 2, and 3-audited infrastructure) and are penetration-tested by an independent firm annually.
5. Can you have our program set up and ready to launch in under an hour?
Long implementations delay the recruiting and retention value you are buying, and consume HR time. Ask for the steps, who does each one, and how long monthly administration takes once you are live.
Peanut Butter’s answer: About one hour: 15 minutes online and a 45-minute Program Initiation call. Monthly administration takes about 20 minutes.
6. Are you proposing a SECURE 2.0 401(k) match that requires us to amend our retirement plan and add the match to nondiscrimination testing?
A SECURE 2.0 401(k) match doesn’t reduce the loan balance, requires a plan amendment, asks employees to certify their loan payments, and is included in the plan’s ACP nondiscrimination test. Ask whether the vendor’s recommendation actually pays down student debt, and what it adds to your compliance work.
Peanut Butter’s answer: We recommend Section 127 direct repayment: tax-free, permanent, and no retirement plan changes. See the comparison.