Contribution tiers
For employers who want to attract and retain college-educated talent: whether to tier contributions, made simple.
Best practice
No contribution tiers: one flat monthly amount for every participant.
- The most successful plans keep it simple.
- A modest flat amount makes a noticeable difference.
Good to know
Tiers can be based only on tenure or time in the program. They reward longer service, but employees have more to understand and HR has more to manage. Peanut Butter supports tiered plans if you need one.
Questions employers ask
Peanut Butter supports tiered plans based on tenure or time in the program, but most successful plans keep it simple with one flat dollar amount. A modest contribution makes a noticeable difference.
- Start low and grow. Begin with a modest monthly contribution and consider increasing it in the second plan year.
- Keep it simple. Make the program available to all full-time employees, just as most companies offer health insurance.
- Share accountability. Employees remain responsible for their minimum payments; your contributions help them get out of debt faster.
Notes
- Peanut Butter client data, where aggregated data analysis has been authorized: Student Loan Repayment plans, 2016–2026, as of November 2026. Each employer is counted once, by its primary plan (the plan covering the most eligible employees); figures for employees count each eligible employee under their plan; tiered plans are excluded from contribution figures.